My Aunt Bobbie, my dad’s sister, in the photo above between my parents, passed away Monday morning. She, too, had dementia but didn’t live as long as my dad because her beloved husband passed away a few years ago and she could never find joy after losing him. Watching my aunt die of dementia was very sad but, as with my dad, the overall emotion is relief that she is no longer suffering. I can tell a lot of people don’t understand the part about feeling relief when someone has died. If you haven’t lost someone you love to the slow death of dementia, I imagine it’s hard to envision feeling relief. At the time of her passing, my aunt’s personality was so far removed from the woman she used to be it would have been cruel to wish her to live longer. Now she can be free. Now she can go and do whatever it is we do when we leave here. I’m not sure exactly what happens but I do believe we go to a place where all the good you can possibly imagine comes true.

Lately I’ve been thinking about how we learn to say goodbye to someone who is dying. I’ve come to realize that the goodbye is my own internal process, my letting go. Everyday I am met with countless moments that offer me the practice of letting go. When I make a mistake, I have a choice: let my mind run over and over what I did causing me more pain or let go of the episode and not beat myself up about it. When I eat a lot of sugar, which puts me into a sugar coma, I can either ruminate over the fact that I’ve been struggling with this compulsion for most of my life or accept what I did, let it go and see what I can learn from it. Several years ago I made peace with being single after having had many, many years of pain and suffering because of it. Letting go of that allowed me to see that I am actually happy on my own. These days I am letting go of worrying about being about 20 lbs overweight. I find it brings me more peace to focus, instead, on how strong and healthy I am.

Perhaps these smaller acts of letting go help prepare me for the bigger ones, like saying goodbye to my dad and my aunt. Maybe my ease with letting go these days was made possible by the nonstop practicing I’ve had my entire adult life, working to break free from the worry and thoughts that have held me prisoner. Maybe every single day is a chance to apply the art of saying goodbye in lots of tiny ways.

Godspeed Aunt Bobbie. Tell my dad I miss him when you see him.

I’ve been working at my new nursing job for two weeks now and I love it. I was hired to do start of care assessments for a home health agency but what I’m really doing is meeting angels disguised as humans. I’m falling in love with most of them and it’s reminding me that even a city like Miami, which is pushing all my internal buttons, is filled with lovely people and many opportunities to focus on love.

I drive to the homes of our clients which translates to being in traffic a lot of the time I’m in my car. My friend, Kimberly, says my car is a church on wheels because it’s been said that with enough prayers and intention, one person can effect the attitudes of many people around them. So, every time I get in my church on wheels, and right now it’s Gretchen, my mom’s Volkswagen beetle while she’s in Canada, I set my intention for safety and smooth traffic flow. Believe me when I say it’s a challenge for me to maintain a sense of peace while driving in Miami. I’ve lived in many places and traveled a lot but I’ve never quite experienced anything like Miami drivers. The drivers here make New York City, notorious for its aggression and insolence, seem like the calmest, kindest place on earth. I am pushed, daily, to find a different way to deal with the anger I so often feel when confronted with a city that seems, in my opinion, to be mired in hostility.

I heard something on the show Addicted to Food recently that goes something like this: in any situation you can either react from anger or respond from love. I think about that almost every single day now. My goal is to come from love in every situation. I am far from that becoming a reality but I practice it every day, a lot. Here’s an example: I was walking with my dog, Ellie, yesterday morning. I tie her leash around my waist when we walk and have to keep focused in case something spooks her or she heads in front of me because I could end up eating the sidewalk like we did the first day we tried this. So, we’re walking and a man on a stand up lawnmower is coming toward us mowing the grass next to the sidewalk. Often, folks doing yard work will stop when I walk by, which I am grateful for. The noise of the mowers and blowers is loud and can send rocks flying and I always say thank you when they stop. This particular man did not pause or move over and Ellie jumped when we passed him, almost pulling me down. I instantly felt anger flare up. I walked past the man then turned around and got his attention and said “Señor, my dog got very scared,” I don’t know if he understood my English, but his hand flew to his heart and he knew what I meant. I could see by the look on his face that he was sorry and probably just hadn’t been paying attention. I moved toward him, grabbed his hand and said “Gracias Señor.” The interaction started with anger but ended with love. The whole thing took about a minute but I walked away filled with compassion and tenderness for a man who had put his hand to his heart when he realized what he’d done. I instantly forgave him. That’s what I mean by angels disguised as humans; like in my job, each person I meet these days seems to be an opportunity for me to practice responding from love. Will I do it each time? Probably not. Is it still my goal? You bet.


Today is Memorial Day. My dad was a WWII veteran and very patriotic so I hung his flag up for him. It is old and faded and rests, folded, on top of the urn that houses his remains. Today it flew in memory of the man he was: conventional, loyal, generous, and principled. Here’s to you dad. Happy Memorial Day.

Before my father passed away, I tried to explain to my friend, Kimberly, what it was like losing my father to dementia. Pretend you are standing at the end of a very long lit hallway. Slowly, starting at the opposite end, the lights start to go off. Sections of the hall become enclosed in darkness and the light is shrinking as the darkness gets closer to where you’re standing. That’s an image of watching a mind vanishing one small piece at a time.

On my cell phone I have ten or eleven saved voice mails my father left for me when he was well. They are the voice of a different man than the one who passed away in January. That man would call me up out of the blue just to tell me he loved me. That man knew I was his daughter and that I was in school studying to become a nurse. That man knew the beautiful woman in his home was his wife and that she was the all time love of his life. That man was proud of his children and grandchildren and loved them with all his heart and knew them by their names and their faces. That man had no idea he would begin fading away long before he left us. If he knew, it would have broken his heart.

I’ve only listened to those voice mails once since my dad passed away. It’s still too soon. I’m still letting go. I’m still saying goodbye in my own personal way. Tears sometimes come to my eyes when I hear a striking piece of music or read something exceptionally beautiful. I will feel a profound sadness and know I am feeling the loss of my dad. This letting go takes time. Saying goodbye to someone we love might be very sacred and it might be what must be done but it is also very hard.


In January of 2007 my dad surprised my mom with a Volkswagen Beetle for their 50th wedding anniversary. The photo on this post was taken the moment she realized the car was hers. She had dreamed of having a Beetle one day and my dad loved her so much he wanted her to have a car that would make her happy. I love how deeply he loved my mother, you can see it in the way he is holding her. My father loved his life which is why I think it took him a while to let go.

Back in December of 2009 he was starting to struggle with moving around and beginning to experience symptoms of dementia and we had to help him climb into bed each night. He couldn’t make his body move the same way it used to. At bedtime he was so tired his legs would freeze in place walking the few yards between the bathroom and his bed. They literally would not move. We’d say “Come on dad, let’s go.” He’d say “Well, OK” in an enthusiastic voice and my dad, my mother or one of my sisters and I would crack up laughing. A couple of times we laughed so hard I almost peed my pants. My dad was happy. He went with the flow easily and willingly. How could he maintain his positive attitude when his body and mind were working against him? He didn’t let things get to him. I find this remarkable. I whine if I get a headache once in a while or I’m feeling tired. My dad never complained or felt sorry for himself. He kept one foot in front of the other and didn’t give up.

I have a new job as a nurse and yesterday I met an older client who is almost blind and said he’s grateful for every day he gets to put his feet on the ground. Can you imagine? This week I met a woman whose son is a paraplegic with pressure ulcers so bad they are down to the bone. She wasn’t complaining, just telling me her story. When I think I’ve got a problem, it helps me to remember stories of real people dealing with challenging health issues yet still feeling grateful. My dad, the blind gentleman yesterday, the woman and her paralyzed son. That is what I call courage.

There are several things about dying that increase the risks of constipation, an issue that is taken VERY seriously by hospice. A couple of those things are: a lack of mobility makes for sluggish intestines, taking narcotics for pain, and eating low fiber foods. My father did or had all three. Here’s what happened one day last fall when my mom was playing bingo at the Greek Church like she does most Thursdays.

I’m beginning to worry because my dad hasn’t had a good B.M. in a few days. The rule of hospice is to keep the bowels working so there is no impaction which can end up being dangerous, sometimes needing surgical intervention. Since my father is a hospice patient and has a DNR order, the hospital is not an option and we want to avoid impaction at all costs. It can also cause extreme pain for the patient.

Dad is weak and can’t stand up alone and it is very challenging to get him out of bed without someone helping me. For some insane reason I ask him if he needs to poop. He says yes. I know the best way for this to happen is to get him into the bathroom and on the toilet to have gravity do the work of bringing it all down. Miraculously, I get him up from his hospital bed in the family room and arrange him behind his walker. Pushing his walker, he shuffles toward the bedroom with me hanging onto his shirt so he won’t land face down on the floor. He’s so unsteady it’s shocking he doesn’t fall in the hallway and I hold my breath with every step he takes. Somewhere after we’ve turned the corner in the bedroom to head past the dresser, his legs begin to give out and he slides to the floor. Though he weighs less than I do, he and his body do not do what I ask and I could swear he weighs 300 pounds. When I pull, he pushes. When I push, he pulls. He fights me as the dementia kicks in and I feel like I’m with someone who is no longer my father, this is a stranger who will not do what I want him to do. He’s pooped in his diaper so I have to change him while he is lying on the floor. I do this by rolling him side to side, trying not to get poop on the rug. I am getting very upset and very angry and he laughs at me. I see he is bleeding from a skin tear on his tissue thin skin. There is blood on the yellow carpet. Great. I put a pillow under his head and try to figure out what to do. I attempt to lift him and he ends up sliding across the carpet. I go to the living room to look outside to see if either of our two male neighbors are home. Both their vehicles are gone. Crap. I can’t call 911 because he is DNR and I don’t dare take a chance of anyone wanting or trying to do any kind of heroic thing with him. I don’t want to call my mom because she needs bingo to get a break from all of this. I try calling her several times but she doesn’t answer. I also do not want to admit I can’t handle this. I am a new nurse and I want to prove I have what it takes. Stupid thinking but there it is. Now I am very upset. I am sobbing and somehow I’ve transported myself back to childhood and it’s all my dad’s fault, lying there smiling at me with sarcasm in his eyes. This is not a situation I am proud of but stress and helplessness have taken over my rational mind. I leave the room and go cry in the family room. I go back into the bedroom and try to lift him onto the bed. No luck. I do this several times. I am exhausted and I know my father must be as well. Every time I try to lift him and can’t, I go and cry and gather myself and decide to try again. It’s been about an hour and a half and I can’t believe I am unable to lift this feeble man. Finally I am able to heave him up on the edge of the bed and drag him onto it, his body resting across mine. This gives me hope. I maneuver him to a sitting position, pull him into his wheelchair and bring him back to his bed. I am spent. He is exhausted. I can see it in his face. Getting him back into his bed is a breeze compared to what just happened. I settle him into bed and apologize for losing my temper. I think he may have smiled. I probably leaned over him and said “time for a hug dad,” and “I love you.” Like I always do.

The gift

On our refrigerator is the same photo of my dad and me that accompanies this blog post. It was taken on Christmas day and was the last time he went outside. Marla, my dad’s Certified Nurses Assistant and now our dear friend, took the photo and we have it displayed in a prominent place so we can look at it whenever we want to.

This morning I was trying to find the inspiration to write and couldn’t find it until I looked at the photo. What always strikes me when I look at it is the look of complete vulnerability on my dad’s face. If you knew him you could also see, maybe it comes across even if you don’t, that he is not happy. He has a grimace on his face and because I knew him so well, I believe he felt confused and possibly annoyed that we got him up and dressed and out to the front porch. It was a bit cool and we dressed him in one of his very old cashmere golfing sweaters with a t-shirt underneath. We wanted to make sure he didn’t get cold because of his lack of body fat to insulate him. He is looking at me intently and I don’t remember what I was saying to him. We are making eye contact and because of his delicate state, I believe there is trust in the way he is looking at me and the way he is holding tightly to my hand. By this time, three weeks before his death, he barely had any vocabulary left in him. He was  increasingly non-verbal as the dementia claimed more of his brain.

Though I doubt it is a conscious decision, a person in my father’s condition is forced to turn over their independence to their caretakers. It happens in stages as they lose control over every aspect of their lives. I become my father’s voice. I was his advocate. Because I was his nurse, my family supported me in taking on this role. My mother and sisters were incredibly supportive in the decisions we made to discontinue all non-palliative medications and to not force him to eat when it became clear he no longer wanted to. We were a team joined in the common goals of making my father as comfortable as possible and having his passing be peaceful and surrounded by his loved ones.

I was my father’s voice. As the weeks passed he became more and more like an infant. He could not talk or walk or take care of himself. Though there were many difficult moments with my father’s combativeness and my reactions to those moments, it was imperative that I respect how I knew my father wanted his last months to look like. I had to put aside all control of how I thought things should be and instead do what I knew in my heart he would want done. My awareness of how my father wanted the end of his life to look like was something intuited from conversations I’d had with him through the years. I had a deep understanding of how he felt about prolonging a life that was trying to leave. We knew but failed to remember he had a living will so we didn’t think to look for it. We found it after he passed away when my sister Jody was going through a small strong box of his papers. His living will spelled out exactly what we had intuitively done for him. He wanted no heroics of any kind. He asked that food and water not be forced when it was clear that death was imminent. He asked that all medications, except those for comfort, be discontinued. He asked that he be allowed to die with dignity and the living will, in it’s beautiful, poetic form, gave us permission to let him go, asked us to let him go. He wanted this and we followed his wishes exactly, never having read the living will. To love and respect someone is to honor their wishes in spite of what we think is right for them. There cannot possibly be anything more beautiful than carrying out the dying wishes of someone you love. The ultimate act of kindness and love is to step aside and allow this voiceless soul their final choice. This is the greatest gift you can give and you will never do anything more honorable. Nothing. Period.


Dying is as sacred as birth but it’s heartbreaking instead of joyful, as most births tend to be. Nothing compares to the loss of someone we love, it leaves a hole in our hearts that never completely repairs itself. We go on, we live our lives, we fall in love, but we are never quite the same again.

In some ways my father’s illness was a blessing. His decline took him away in fragments, leaving us ample time to say goodbye, each in our own way. For me, as his main caretaker, I sacrificed him knowing I was his daughter for feeling complete when he was gone. I had the luxury of time to make peace with any unresolved issues I had left in me. The more vulnerable he became, the more tender I was, for the most part.

In the spur of the moment, my father’s dementia could make him combative and angry and often I was the brunt of it. I was not always proud of how I reacted when he tried to fight me in those demented moments. Sometimes, forgetting his behavior was an illness, I would react in anger toward him then later, once in bed, would sob at how I had treated him. My heart would break and I would pray for forgiveness and to become more patient and loving. It gave me a clear picture of why war doesn’t work. Anger responding to anger cannot create peace. It only escalates into pain for both sides. One of the participants must back down and turn in the other direction and resolve to behave differently. That’s what I began practicing. There were hard and painful lessons but love was the prevailing force between my father and me during those months. Today, almost four months since he passed away, I know the choice I made to come home and care for him was the best choice I ever made. I know what I shared with him was beautiful and difficult and extremely profound and nothing in my life will ever quite match it.

Long goodbye

I had no idea my father would be my first patient when I decided, at the age of 50, to go to nursing school. It’s funny how life sometimes turns out completely different from what you thought it would be. Before I graduated in spring of 2010 I decided I would move home to Miami to help care for my father who had become a hospice patient at home with the official diagnosis of end stage cerebral degeneration, also known as dementia. I was a full-time nursing student in the Ithaca, NY area and felt it was the right decision to come home after graduation to help my mom care for my dad. I have always lived my life by following my heart rather than anyone’s idea of how I should live and my heart was telling me this is what I needed to do.

The idea began to form when I was home the Christmas before and saw how he had declined. At that time my father was walking, unsteadily, with his cane and refusing to use a walker, which he gravely needed. It took him a long time to do anything. Though his cognitive abilities were diminished, he was fully verbal. He was experiencing confusion and some paranoid delusions but he still knew who we all were. His attitude was positive and upbeat and he never complained about his predicament. He voiced frustration but expressed it in a humorous way. Years before macular degeneration had taken away his ability to read but now I noticed he was no longer listening to books on tape, something he’d previously done daily.

He was incontinent of urine and was wearing pull-up diapers which he was mostly able to manage on his own. My sister Susan was the first of his three daughters to help with his diapers. She did it naturally, simply doing what had to be done. I was dreading my first time but the day came, I helped him and thought “well, there’s my dad’s penis. Interesting.” It became the new normal. The new normal is what I like to call things in life that change and I have to get used to doing something in a new and different way. The Christmas of 2009 was when I realized, way down deep, that my father was leaving us. The man and the father he had been was beginning to fade. I’ve always believed some people come back full circle to infancy at the end of their lives and I knew then my father was going to be one of those people and that this was the beginning of his long goodbye.


My dad passed away on January 20th at 10:40 A.M. Some days I might think about him a few times, other days I may not have even a conscious thought of him. Today is the kind of day where I am viscerally aware of the loss of him. The space he used to inhabit that is now empty. The physical space in the family room where his hospital bed was as well as the space inside of my heart. Yesterday I looked at photos of him a month before he died, days before he died, the night before he died, then after he was gone. I need these photos to remind me of what I shared with him those last months of his life, they are a testament to the moments that have changed me and formed the woman I am now.  Those final days are seared into my cells yet I find I cannot recall them exactly as they were. What I have are the photos, they tell his story because I do not want to forget it.

The night before he died, watching him and realizing he was finally, after so long, leaving. Sitting up with him, watching his increased breathing, the profuse sweating, feeling helpless to take away this difficulty that was his body trying to sustain itself for a few more hours. The profound sacredness of that night after my mother, exhausted, finally went to bed. After the hospice nurse came to assess him and to order the continuous care I realized I needed. Putting on the special music he loved that I had chosen for him to die to. Playing it hour after hour as I watched him slipping away. Sitting by my father’s bedside waiting, watching, praying for a gentle release, and knowing that sharing this last night with him was the most important thing I would ever do in my life. Night turned into morning. The sun came up. The nurse arrived and two and a half hours later he was gone. I have the photos to remind me of what happened, to show me that being able to say goodbye to my father was his final gift to me. Godspeed dad.